posted
Subtitle / Alternate Title: What do the Borg Nanoprobes Need with Flesh and How Did the Borg Avoid the Nanite Sentience Problem?
In "Drone"[VOY5], a super-drone is created when a transporter mishap mixes the Doctor's 29th Century future-tech portable holo-emitter and some of Seven of Nine's Borg nanoprobes. The be-nanoprobed holo-emitter is thought to merely be damaged and is left alone in a lab for later repair.
Instead, the emitter is assimilated, and the new Borgified hardware assimilates other nearby equipment and, later, takes a sample of DNA for a biological template. After a day of super-speed maturation, the super-drone emerges.
What's amazing here is that the entire plot of the episode is based around the idea that stray nanoprobes from Seven of Nine which merged with the portable holo-emitter assimilated it, extrapolated its technologies and developed new capabilities therefrom, developed a plan to extract a tissue sample so that the DNA (and presumably the cellular material) could be used as a biological template from which to begin crafting a full-size lifeform, designed and built a unique Borg maturation chamber out of assorted nearby Federation components, and so on.
Let's look at a few choice bits, with thanks as always to Chakoteya.net:
SEVEN: This technology resembles a Borg maturation chamber, but many of the components are unfamiliar. CREWMAN: Commander. SEVEN: He was punctured by an extraction tubule. It removed a tissue sample. There are residual nanoprobes surrounding the wound. Their encoding sequences are identical to my own. TUVOK: Your nanoprobes? How? SEVEN: I don't know. TUVOK: Take him to Sickbay. What are you doing? SEVEN: I will be recognised as Borg. A drone, but unlike any I've ever seen. TUVOK: It appears to be in the foetal stage. SEVEN: I don't understand. The Borg assimilate. They do not reproduce in this fashion.
JANEWAY: Where did he come from? SEVEN: I believe it was created here in the science lab. When the away team beamed back to Voyager there was a transporter malfunction. Our patterns merged briefly. It is possible that some of my nanoprobes infected the Doctor's mobile emitter. TUVOK: They began to assimilate. SEVEN: Yes. Nanoprobes are encoded to utilize any technology they encounter. Once it assimilated the emitter, it began to transform this diagnostic station. When Ensign Mulchaey entered the room, they sampled his DNA. JANEWAY: Using his genetic code as a template to create a lifeform.
EMH: Well, he appears to be human for the most part. Borg implants comprise approximately [Astrometrics lab] EMH [OC]: Twenty seven percent of his body. TUVOK: Curious. His body plating is composed of polydutonic alloy EMH [on monitor]: Just like my mobile emitter. SEVEN: The nanoprobes must have extrapolated that technology. It could explain his unique design. TORRES: Wait a minute. The Doctor's emitter came from the twenty ninth century. It's five hundred years more advanced that anything we've got. TUVOK: It is logical to assume this drone will be equally advanced. TORRES: A twenty ninth century Borg. TUVOK: In essence. EMH [on monitor]: I've located my mobile emitter. It's embedded in his cerebral cortex. SEVEN: The emitter has been adapted to serve as part of his central nervous system. It controls all autonomic functions. EMH: That means we can't remove it. Not without killing the drone. TUVOK: Has it contacted the Borg collective? SEVEN: No. I have dampened it's proximity transceiver. TORRES: For now. What about when it grows up?
[Ready room] JANEWAY: Reactive body armour? Multidimensional adaptability? Internal transporter nodes? SEVEN: The drone possesses superior technology. It will fully mature in less than two hours. However, its Borg shielding is not yet active. We can still terminate it, but we must act quickly. JANEWAY: Hold on a minute, Seven. I want some answers first. What normally happens when a drone disengages from the maturation chamber? SEVEN: It awaits instructions from the Collective.
Y'know, I really don't know why the drone would await instructions from the Collective. The nanoprobes themselves seem to be quite capable of independent thought and creativity, if not individually than at least in aggregate. As of "Inside Man"[VOY7], Seven is said to have 3.6 million nanoprobes within her. Assuming they are evenly distributed, then only some thousands could've infected the mobile emitter just based on a quickie volumetric guesstimate.
And yet, these thousands, perhaps with computing support from the mobile emitter itself, were sufficient to do a great many things. Extrapolating technology and designing new things from it is not exactly child's play. All this having been said and pondered for awhile, it wasn't until I was writing the paragraph above that I realized that the mobile emitter's computing power could have been tapped for these tasks, and after the relevant technologies aboard it were extrapolated and duplicated, the emitter itself was 'discarded' as a mere nervous system controller.
Still, however, Seven's statements are clear that the nanoprobes themselves are designed to do precisely what they did, which in this case was to assimilate . . . to take control of . . . and make good use of a 29th Century device which, it goes without saying, they had never encountered before. Even if they adapted its processing power for their own tasks to aid in later design efforts, they remain amazing for being able to do that.
Certainly we've seen near-magical transformations of NX Class engineering components with nothing more than the injection of Borg nanoprobes, as seen in "Regeneration" when a drone simply injects a plain-ish area and Borgifies it, so this seems to follow.
Put simply, the nanoprobes are extraordinary tools, and given their capabilities it is interesting to ponder something like the Borg having their own SG-1 Replicator moment . . . after all, if they're so capable, why do they need the fleshy bits at all? Why do they need the Queen? Certainly the Queen's resurrection could be nicely explained if she were merely a manifestation of the nanoprobes. But, then, why just one? Why not have queens everywhere?
And while we're pondering, it's easy to ponder that the Borg may have been conquered by their own technology . . . turning the Borg into victims of a Terminator or Galactica-esque failure to contain their own creation.
We can even imagine it starting again. Can you imagine a Borg Civil War fought between drones and their nanoprobes? SG-1 Replicators, eat your heart out.
Registered: Nov 2001
| IP: Logged
posted
I was going to make a childish joke about nanites in Seven's poo assimilating her toilet, but the more I got to consider the ramifications... The whole thing falls apart as soon as you start to think about it.
Seven - and any other Borg - would be excreting and egesting nanoprobes all the time. Like the Thing in, er, The Thing, once free of the host they become their own entities with their own programming to assimilate and adapt. By that logic the Borg couldn't even exist at all, they'd just be a massive Grey Goo outbreak.
posted
A. Nanites are part of the collective consciousness of the Borg and can't display individual thought, much like the drones they inhabit.
B. The Borg have some sort mental dampener which prevents the nanites from gaining sentience, the way the skin job cylons controlled the centurions and raiders in nuBSG.
C. The nanites aren't as sophisticated as Wesley's nanites, and the Voyager crew is easily impressed. Speaking of which, Wesley's nanites should be giving the Q a run for their money by the time of Voyager considering their rapid evolution.
Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
quote:Originally posted by Lee: a massive Grey Goo outbreak.
That's an outbreak of "Grey Poo", get it right.
Perhaps there's a range limit for a nanoprobe . . . sort of an electronic fence, as it were, unless they're being sent out via the tubules. The transporter event might have caused the nanoprobes to not be deactivated as they normally might, or due to some other malfunction caused them to activate as they might if exiting through the tubules.
(It depends on whether it is an active deactivator or an active activator, if you will, though there are other options.)
We know from some episode or other where Seven is mildly injured that nanoprobes can leak out, but I don't recall their activity level, though it was discussed. In any case, the tubules suggest a lower limit for assimilation . . . a few nanoprobes can't seem to do much, but hundreds or thousands can.
-------------------- . . . ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam.
quote:Originally posted by Mars Needs Women: A. Nanites are part of the collective consciousness of the Borg and can't display individual thought, much like the drones they inhabit.
Ah, but it seems like they'd have to have a connection to the collective to maintain that. Given the apparent ease with which at least Federation-style systems can accidentally achieve sentience (here I imagine some superior race noting that their computing system anti-sentience safeguards are virtually non-existent), one can imagine a collection of nanoprobes, especially with badass computer support in the form of the holo-emitter's processing systems, coming into their own even if they normally wouldn't.
Unless we go with your dampener idea, that is, either hard-wired or software-encoded at a basic level.
quote:C. The nanites aren't as sophisticated as Wesley's nanites, and the Voyager crew is easily impressed. Speaking of which, Wesley's nanites should be giving the Q a run for their money by the time of Voyager considering their rapid evolution.
This leads to another thought. If a nanite or ten entered a Borg, would it be ignored by the other nanoprobes cruising around the bloodstream just like the Borg ignore folks who beam aboard?
Hmm . . . there's a story idea, there, if someone hasn't used it already.
-------------------- . . . ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam.
quote:Originally posted by Guardian 2000: Put simply, the nanoprobes are extraordinary tools, and given their capabilities it is interesting to ponder something like the Borg having their own SG-1 Replicator moment . . . after all, if they're so capable, why do they need the fleshy bits at all?
There is a theory that I've talked at length about with a friend that plays STO that posits the following:
The Borg evolved as sentient machines a long time ago; it was they that altered V'ger. These purely machine Borg battled the Iconians, who then developed their computer virus to defeat the Borg. As a defense to this, the Borg started adapting organic components to their technology to combat the computer virus and were able to push back the Iconians from their region of space.
-------------------- I haul cardboard and cardboard accessories
Registered: Mar 1999
| IP: Logged
posted
I like it, though the Vaadwuar dismissing the Borg as losers with only a few star systems hundreds of years ago would suggest they ought not have been whipping Iconian ass 200,000 years ago. Not to mention the Borg apparently never getting their hands on the Iconian gateways.
That'd be deep poo-poo right there. It's bad enough they have been shown to do time travel . . . they should've just seeded the universe with nanoprobes shortly after the Big Bang and then they'd have been done with it. ;-)
Despite Guinan's reference to thousands of centuries, Voyager seemed to strongly put the Borg as a race that had only been expanding for a thousand years or so.
Random fact: That's titled "The Borg Have Been Busy" . . . my blog post from which the opening post came is titled "The Borg Have Been Busy II: Assimilation Boogaloo."
-------------------- . . . ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam.
posted
I just had the thought that the nanoprobes are essentially Von Neumann machines. Individually they just make more of themselves, but when combined they begin to specialize. Which is also exactly how we got from single-celled organisms to multi-celled organisms, too.
As for the "grey poo" line of thought, it's clear the nanoprobes are mobile and directed, so I'm sure the concentration is not even across the whole body. They almost certainly would move out of the intestines before they're flushed out. And they probably focus on the parts of the body where they're needed most, so there'd be higher concentrations there.
-------------------- “Those people who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do.” — Isaac Asimov Star Trek Minutiae | Memory Alpha
Registered: Nov 2000
| IP: Logged
Printer-friendly view of this topic
