T O P I C ��� R E V I E W
|
Starship Freak
Member # 293
|
posted
Wow, cool new ship and totally unexpected in this episode! Look at trekmovie.com for a picture. It has a spherical primary hull reminiscent of Hope/Olympic-class TNG-ship, weird-looking secondary hull with odd blueglowing section (can�t be engines?) and 7 possibly 8 "tailpipes". Finallly, standard-looking nacelles indicating starfleet type ship. It looks small, so a transport? (it was called a medusan ship by someone at trekbbs, but apparently this was not mentioned in the actual episode)
BTW, is noone capping these new episodes for starshippics? I know trekcore does and does a bangup job as well, but noone here on this board?
|
Guardian 2000
Member # 743
|
posted
Errr . . . where the hell did the Medusan planet go? That *was* where they were supposed to be going, instead of to a rendezvous with a ship.
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
I believe that was the original problem with the episode. The Enterprise clearly heads for a planet, but Kirk says something to the effect of "We've rendezvoused with the Medusan vessel." So unless the Medusans use entire planets as starships, this was an error.
|
Starship Freak
Member # 293
|
posted
Well, the transfer could well be with a ship instead of a planetful of beings that just looking at will kill you.
Btw, I noticed there is a lively debate on this topic in the general trek forum here on Solar Flare on page 10 on the Topic: New station for "The Ultimate Computer". Wow, I can�t believe I missed that ;-)
|
Harry
Member # 265
|
posted
The tailpipes remind me of slightly clumsy version of this style of spaceship.
|
Sean
Member # 2010
|
posted
Whew, 1940... It looks like it has a gas tank.
|
Mars Needs Women
Member # 1505
|
posted
Let's all move this back to my thread, shall we.
|
AndrewR
Member # 44
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by Harry: The tailpipes remind me of slightly clumsy version of this style of spaceship.
That ship looks more like the Mon Calamari ships from Star Wars Episode VI: The Return of the Jedi.
|
Timo
Member # 245
|
posted
To be sure, our Starfleet heroes could be transporting the Medusan only part of the way. Perhaps the Medusans want to keep the exact location of their homeworld secret from the rest of the galaxy?
Then again, the real destination might be the Medusan planet, as originally shown, and Miranda Jones was speaking of an entirely different sort of "vessel" where she and Kollos would "join" - something more akin to a ceremonial urn or a jacuzzi tub.
..What bothered me more was that they never say which planet they are transporting Kollos from!
The Medusan vessel certainly looks pretty in the Trekmovie caps. How big is she? The window rows would suggest she's level with the Enterprise and behind her, and thus perhaps half her length. But is she in front of and below Kirk's ship instead, and much smaller?
The nacelles are so conventional (they even seem to have the red cheat lines and the yellow banana thing) that this ship probably is in Starfleet registry and of generic Federation manufacture, even if with some native Medusan tweaks to the sensors and whatnot. A nice design for a courier or sigint vessel.
Timo Saloniemi
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim
Member # 646
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by Timo:
The window rows would suggest she's level with the Enterprise and behind her, and thus perhaps half her length.
Huh? It certainly doesn't look like she's further away from the camera than the E to me... quote: But is she in front of and below Kirk's ship instead, and much smaller?
Yes, I think.
|
Daniel Butler
Member # 1689
|
posted
This is all being discussed on the other thread, including windows, size, Medusan/Federation tech, etc
|