T O P I C ��� R E V I E W
|
Baloo
Member # 5
|
posted
Found this in The Straight Dope archive."Does the head remain briefly conscious after decapitation?" ------------------ My mind wanders, but don't worry. It's weak and can't get very far. --Steve Allen www.geocities.com/Area51/Shire/8641/
|
TSN
Member # 31
|
posted
Well, there's something I could have done without...Anyway, even if the thing at the beginning about blinking were true, it's possible he could have started blinking before decapitation, and continued afterwards w/o consciousness. Like the way a chicken's body continues to move after the head is removed. ------------------ "It'd be a pity if every pencil on Earth suddenly collapsed in on itself and blew everything up." -Krenim, TNO chat, September 30, 1999
|
RW
Member # 27
|
posted
Further reading: http://www.logp.dk/guillotine/Pages/30sec.html Excellent site on the guillotine BTW. And I say that without suicidal tendencies Lee.
|
Kosh
Member # 167
|
posted
People usually pass out within five seconds of haveing their oxygen cut off, and I can't think of a better way to cut off oxygen!!!------------------ "One Tequila, Two Tequila, Three Tequila, Floor". George Carlin
|
Feste
|
posted
Perhaps he was just winking and flirting.
|
RW
Member # 27
|
posted
I mean, like, did you know guillotines had a splatter screen? (dig that man!) :]
|
Sol System
Member # 30
|
posted
Oh, these are nothing. I know of a site dedicated to one woman's fetish regarding the guillotine. I'll see if I can find the link.------------------ "Quadrilateral I was, now I warp like a smile." -- Soul Coughing
|
deadcujo
Member # 13
|
posted
Have any of you read the book "If we could keep a severed head alive..."? ------------------ The Unknown Vulcan http://www.phix-it.com/~perseus/
|
Diane
Member # 53
|
posted
Deadcujo: Whoa, that just reminded me of those heads kept alive in jars from Futurama.Kosh: "People usually pass out within five seconds of haveing their oxygen cut off, and I can't think of a better way to cut off oxygen!!!" What do you mean? Certainly people can hold their breathes longer than that. ------------------ --Then, said Cranly, do you not intend to become a protestant? --I said that I had lost the faith, Stephen answered, but not that I had lost self-respect. What kind of liberation would that be to forsake an absurdity which is logical and coherent and to embrace one which is illogical and incoherent? James Joyce, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man.
|
deadcujo
Member # 13
|
posted
I really doubt someone would try to hold their breath after getting their head chopped off. They'd be too frightened and stuff. For anyone who really wants to know more about severed heads, I really suggest that book ------------------ The Unknown Vulcan http://www.phix-it.com/~perseus/
[This message has been edited by DeadCujo (edited October 15, 1999).]
|
Baloo
Member # 5
|
posted
When you hold your breath, your blood is still circulating. Oxygenated blood is still travelling to and from your (not empty) lungs, scavenging whatever oxygen is left from the air inside them. That's why CPR works, even though the breath you breathe into a victim comes from your lungs. There's still a lot oxygen left.Your blood hasn't always given up all the oxygen in it by the time it returns to your heart for recirculation either, especially if you are lying still. I can see where the sudden cessation of circulation might cause more rapid loss of consciousness than simply holding one's breath. Despite what you may imagine, the quick severing of the neck and spine caused by the guillotine blade is not the immediate, or even primary cause of death. The complete lack of freshly-oxygenated blood reaching the brain is what does the trick. A person would tend to lose consciousness very rapidly, though there would, of course, be considerable variation from one individual to the next. "I gotta get a head!" --The Headless Horseman ------------------ My mind wanders, but don't worry. It's weak and can't get very far. --Steve Allen www.geocities.com/Area51/Shire/8641/ [This message has been edited by Baloo (edited October 15, 1999).]
|
The First One
Member # 35
|
posted
Well, yes, but the sheer shock and trauma of the amputation would probably cause immediate loss of consciousness, thereby making the question moot.------------------ Looking at cleavage is like looking at the sun. You don't stare at it. It's too risky. You get a sense of it and then you look away! - Jerry Seinfeld Starfleet Weapons & Tactics
|
RW
Member # 27
|
posted
And it's a pretty neat cut too. In medieval times, I don't think the axe always landed on your neck..rather..higher? Nice thoughts for a friday afternoon. i'm twisted. Rowl!
|
Kosh
Member # 167
|
posted
And the spine would go first, so no sensation. Grewsome, but humain!! Gotta love it.------------------ "One Tequila, Two Tequila, Three Tequila, Floor". George Carlin
|
RW
Member # 27
|
posted
Oh, before anyone forgets:THIS WILL NOT TURN INTO A DEATH PENALTY THREAD!
|
Omega
Member # 91
|
posted
IIRC, you were lucky if you got decapitated in one stroke. It sometimes took three or four.------------------ "I consider the foundation of the Constitution as laid on this ground: That "all powers not delegated to the United States, by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States or to the people . . ." To take a single step beyond the boundaries thus specially drawn around the powers of Congress is to take possession of a boundless field of power, no longer susceptible of any definition." - Thomas Jefferson to George Washington, 1791
|
TSN
Member # 31
|
posted
I wonder, how do you determine when the person is dead? When their head dies, when their body dies, or both?------------------ "It'd be a pity if every pencil on Earth suddenly collapsed in on itself and blew everything up." -Krenim, TNO chat, September 30, 1999
|
Baloo
Member # 5
|
posted
Actually, I suppose death comes when enough of one or the other sustains enough damage to render it nonfunctional. If your brain dies, the body will likely soon follow. Likewise, the body will not last long without extensive intervention if the brain takes a hike.Actually, I'll bet the guillotine isn't painless. It's just that you'd only feel the incision along your neck. I would guess that the nerves which send pain signals to the brain attach above the point where the neck would be severed. On the other hand, I once knew a friend who was a Vietnam vet who had been shot once or twice during his tour. He said that he didn't feel any pain for a few minutes. He knew he'd been hit, but his adrenal glands must've gone into overdrive. My personal theory (bolstered by wee-hours collisions betwixt my toes and furniture) is that when an injury occurs, it can take several seconds before the sensation registers as pain. It's as if the nerves are saying: "Uh-oh! This is bad! Somebody's gotta tell the brain about this!""Oh, no, I ain't telling the brain! You tell the brain!" "Not me!" "Well, somebody's gotta do it!" "Tell ya what. We'll tell the brain on the count of three." "Okay, I'll count: One, Two..." "Wait! Wait! Just how bad is it?" "I dunno, but the eyes just had a look. We'd better say something now!" And so forth. Actually, the Guillotine was, if not invented, then at least perfected by French physician Joseph-Ignace Guillotin. He developed and tested (on cadavers) a "machine" that would be, in the opinion of the medical community at that time (1792) a more humane form of execution than the methods currently being employed. Here's a link to a site that gives a bit more detail: The guillotine. --Baloo ------------------ My mind wanders, but don't worry. It's weak and can't get very far. --Steve Allen www.geocities.com/Area51/Shire/8641/
|
Omega
Member # 91
|
posted
DeadCujo:Of course they wouldn't try to hold their breath after their head was chopped off. They'd have nothing to hold it in! ------------------ "I consider the foundation of the Constitution as laid on this ground: That "all powers not delegated to the United States, by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States or to the people . . ." To take a single step beyond the boundaries thus specially drawn around the powers of Congress is to take possession of a boundless field of power, no longer susceptible of any definition." - Thomas Jefferson to George Washington, 1791
|
deadcujo
Member # 13
|
posted
I just meant they wouldn't have time to even think about it ------------------ The Unknown Vulcan http://www.phix-it.com/~perseus/
|
|