T O P I C ��� R E V I E W
|
AndrewR
Member # 44
|
posted
OK so I was looking at some trek news and I stumbled across news about that online fan film project New Voyages - the one where they 'recast' the original series characters - not the one on the Exeter... err called Exeter I think.
Anyway - wow - I can't believe all the people clamouring to be a part of it.
Grace Lee Whitney, Walter Koenig, George Takei, David Gerrold (writer of Troubles with TribbleS), the writer of "Far Beyond the Stars" - a writer that wrote some scripts for Star Trek Phase II and D.C. Fontana!
What's the quality of this one like?
|
Kazeite
Member # 970
|
posted
... Well, they have decent sets, good sfx, good costumes, usual amateur acting... and really weird scripts
I mean, last one, no one could understand without special "episode timeline FAQ"
|
B.J.
Member # 858
|
posted
I've seen some of it. Personally, I can't get over the rotten acting. That, and the Elvis clone playing Kirk.
B.J.
|
Lee
Member # 393
|
posted
Never buy anything prop-related from that guy. He's a complete tosser. Just a word to the wise, like.
|
Aban Rune
Member # 226
|
posted
Is this the one we watched the trailer for not too long ago... where they beam down and find the wrecked saucer of the Kongo?
If that's it, I definitely remember the impressive sets and SFX. The captain is really bad, though.
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim
Member # 646
|
posted
No, that's Exeter. In this one they go back in time through the Guardian of Forever and find Commodore Jefferies living on Earth in present times, with the Constellation's shuttlecraft in his garage. Also, somehow the Planet Killers (more than one now) are connected to the Guardian, and there's some kind of massive war going on across multiple temporal fronts that ultimately requires the Pike-era, TOS-era, and Movie-era Enterprises and their crews to team up in a gigantic CGI fanboy-blown wad of crap. Ick.
And yeah, Kirk is played by a professional Elvis impersonator. (I am not kidding.)
|
Aban Rune
Member # 226
|
posted
Crickey.
|
Brown_supahero
Member # 83
|
posted
How many episodes of exeter are there. I thought there were more than 2.
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim
Member # 646
|
posted
Well, there's not even a complete second episode yet, actually. "The Tressaurian Intersection" is still in post-production, though it's being released in segments and the first two (the teaser and Act I) have been released already on www.starshipexeter.com, with the rest forthcoming.
The quality of this second episode, especially in the realms of story and VFX, is markedly improved in comparison to the first, "The Savage Empire." Still, as mentioned, the acting is quite amateur. But hey, it's free, right?
-MMoM
|
Kazeite
Member # 970
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by The Mighty Monkey of Mim: In this one they go back in time through the Guardian of Forever and find Commodore Jefferies living on Earth in present times, with the Constellation's shuttlecraft in his garage.
Actually, it's Enterprise's shuttlecraft, and it's TNG-era Enterprise-A. Yes. TNG era. That Kirk we see there is supposed to be that ressurected Kirk wandering around in TNG era.
And, yes, James Cawley is a proffesional Elvis impersonator. Not that I hold that against him
|
Brown_supahero
Member # 83
|
posted
Isn't there a fan made episodes of the original series that had about 5 episodes?
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim
Member # 646
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by Kazeite: Actually, it's Enterprise's shuttlecraft, and it's TNG-era Enterprise-A. Yes. TNG era. That Kirk we see there is supposed to be that ressurected Kirk wandering around in TNG era.
Whatever.
quote: Originally posted by Brown_supahero: Isn't there a fan made episodes of the original series that had about 5 episodes?
My feeling is that you are indeed probably thinking of New Voyages, but they too have only released two episodes thus far, "Come What May" and "In Harm's Way." Others are supposedly on the way, though.
-MMoM
|
Mars Needs Women
Member # 1505
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by Lee: Never buy anything prop-related from that guy. He's a complete tosser. Just a word to the wise, like.
Why did you buy anything from him?
|
Lee
Member # 393
|
posted
No, but I know plenty of people who did, to their cost.
|
B.J.
Member # 858
|
posted
So, can you enlighten the rest of us about the details?
|
Aban Rune
Member # 226
|
posted
I love hearing stories of worthlessness. Spill.
|
Lee
Member # 393
|
posted
I can't actually remember any of the details off the top of my head, I just remember he was dodgy. I'll try to refresh my memory later.
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim
Member # 646
|
posted
(After a dash of port and a trip to the loo.)
|
OnToMars
Member # 621
|
posted
I downloaded both of these over the break and watched them, and sure, while their quality is questionable, and there are mistakes that reek of the amatuer, you can't easily argue with results, which for them includes getting Walter Koenig to reprise his role as Chekov and having the episode written by D.C. Fontana.
|