T O P I C ��� R E V I E W
|
Reverend
Member # 335
|
posted
This is the last design I steal from the Spaceflight Chronology, I swear.
S.S. Wheeler
|
AndrewR
Member # 44
|
posted
What is the Spaceflight Chronology?
|
AndrewR
Member # 44
|
posted
Nice work by the way!
I reckon after doing that chart that these DY ships could end up morphing toward the Conestoga and the Valiant. Sorta like they've added the phoenix cockpit and nacelles to the body (and removed the coning tower). Works especially for the Conestoga which seems to have those cargo pods below it (which dropped to Terra Nova as their housing or something).
Andrew
|
Aban Rune
Member # 226
|
posted
Spiffy as always.
|
Wraith
Member # 779
|
posted
Do i even need to inflate your ego still furthur by heaping yet more praise on your work?
Oh, i do... fantastic as ever
|
Proteus
Member # 212
|
posted
is this ship named after Scott?
|
Sol System
Member # 30
|
posted
Scott?
John Wheeler, one presumes.
|
MinutiaeMan
Member # 444
|
posted
That's another great design, Kris! I like how you're filling these old hulks in -- these days it's so common to get the usual saucer-and-nacelles designs. Though the really early spaceflight era isn't really too exciting, it's still fun to see these more original configurations.
|
Proteus
Member # 212
|
posted
oh, i only asked cause Scott Wheeler was a makeup artist for DS9 and Voyager that I used to chat with.
|
AndrewR
Member # 44
|
posted
For anyone who didn't see the question... what is the Spaceflight Chronology?
|
Timo
Member # 245
|
posted
It's an early eighties publication that draws a lineage of Earth ship designs from the late 1900s to the 2200s. A chronology based on TOS and TAS, and riding on the publicity of TMP. The text is by two people whose names are more often forgotten than not, but the art is by one Rick Sternbach...
There are graphic timelines there, with 2D b&w images of ships placed on key points. And short articles on "topics of interest" (usually fictional events, but sometimes commentaries on things that were mentioned in TOS or TAS). And then spec pages on important ships, with a color painting of the ship plus technical statistics. The Wheeler is from one such page, IIRC.
Generally, the ships bear virtually no resemblance to anything we saw later on in Trek - it is assumed that early Earth ships did NOT look like clumsier versions of the NCC-1701, but were fundamentally different in shape. And the 2D drawings are often so vague that they don't translate into 3D ships at all, not without a vivid imagination anyway. Rick got quite a bit better in his later years...
Timo Saloniemi
|
Reverend
Member # 335
|
posted
quote: What is the Spaceflight Chronology?
Timo in of course correct, it is an old publication which is quite out of date in may repects which is half the reason I have chosen to incorperate the two DY ships featured within. If you're interestd, someone has been kind enough to dedicat a section of their website to the diagrams and artwork of the chronology, here's the link.
quote: I reckon after doing that chart that these DY ships could end up morphing toward the Conestoga and the Valiant. Sorta like they've added the phoenix cockpit and nacelles to the body (and removed the coning tower). Works especially for the Conestoga which seems to have those cargo pods below it (which dropped to Terra Nova as their housing or something).
That would be quite difficult considering that the Conestoga and the Valiant predatemost of these ships (eveything from DY-500 onwards by my reckoning). I generally consider the DY family to be seperate from most of the better known design lineages, however I have actually decided to go back and flesh out the Valiant Conestoga line sometime down the road.
|
Reverend
Member # 335
|
posted
quote: Spiffy as always.
Cheers
|
Reverend
Member # 335
|
posted
quote: Do i even need to inflate your ego still furthur by heaping yet more praise on your work?
Oh, i do... fantastic as ever
Oh don't worry, my ego is boundless.
|
Reverend
Member # 335
|
posted
quote: That's another great design, Kris! I like how you're filling these old hulks in -- these days it's so common to get the usual saucer-and-nacelles designs. Though the really early spaceflight era isn't really too exciting, it's still fun to see these more original configurations.
Ta very much. This is indeed an obscure and often neglected period in trek ship designs but it's something that I've always had a curiosity for. Perhaps it's because these kinds of early ships are more closely tied in with real science and real physics than say a 23rd or 24th Century starship. Also I kind of like the idea that these vessels are quite primitive and not entirely safe which to me gives them far more character and shows just how dangerous space travel can be.
|
newark
Member # 888
|
posted
I like these designs from the Spaceflight Chronology. They do appear to be very realistic and based on actual science and physics. My only wish is that we could have had something similiar in Enterprise.
|
Wraith
Member # 779
|
posted
I agree with Reverand; I'm also curious about designs of this era; Enterprise could have been better IMO if they'd had a look at designs like this or those on the Starfleet Museum first.
|
The Mike from C.A.P.T.A.I.N.
Member # 709
|
posted
wow thats a helluva site.. especially since ive never found a copy of that book..
couple of quick notes off my quick perusal:
The Baton Rouge class is used as a lot of places, such as John M. Ford's Final Reflection novel. In one of the Marvel comics that came out after TMP, the training vessel Republic was shown to be Baton Rouge-class.
The Tritium-class painting was used to represent the Kobayashi Maru on the cover of the novel with the same name
|
AndrewR
Member # 44
|
posted
I'm not keen on the bubble-with-nacelles design though.
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim
Member # 646
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by The Mike from C.A.P.T.A.I.N.: wow thats a helluva site.. especially since ive never found a copy of that book..
couple of quick notes off my quick perusal:
The Baton Rouge class is used as a lot of places, such as John M. Ford's Final Reflection novel. In one of the Marvel comics that came out after TMP, the training vessel Republic was shown to be Baton Rouge-class.
The Tritium-class painting was used to represent the Kobayashi Maru on the cover of the novel with the same name
These are exactly the kind of little footnotes that I like to have for my shiplist, Captain. Any more pearls of knowledge?
-MMoM
|
CaptainMike
Member # 709
|
posted
The Marvel comic Republic reference is a great example of fandom cohesiveness of the day.. the shot they used of the Republic, shown in a flashback when Cadet Ensign Kirk was serving on it, was traced from the painting shown in the chronology (without the nacelle being detached, though).. it makes a lot more sense for it to be an older ship than a Constitution, as many assume it to be today, even though it was never established as such. The flaw is that the Marvel comic shows the registry NCC-1373.. this was apparently the origin of that erroneous reg that made it into FASA's manuals.
Some other Baton Rouge ships were featured in The Final Reflection, and in a few later comics such as Gary Mitchells previous assignment USS Churchill shown in one of the DC comic annuals
The Mann class was in The Final Reflection also, an amusing seen when the Klingons identified it as the Man-class and thought the humans named a ship after their species
The chronology is also the origin of the timeline that was used in a lot of licensed works, until invalidated by Wrath of Khan's 2283 for the ale reference.. I believe it placed the launch of the Constitution-class in the 2180s, and the birth of the Federation in 2087. This was perpetuated in many books by Carey, the Reeves-Stevens, John M. Ford and some RPG material i believe before chronologies that more resemble Okuda's came into being.
Ive also noticed that Sternbach used many of these designs in his TNG years..the Byrne-class ( http://www.stguardian.to/mixed/spacechron/22ndcentury04.jpg ) looks really familiar.. was it the particle fountain or something from that season?
also, the top view only of the superwarp vessel ( http://www.stguardian.to/mixed/spacechron/superwarp01.jpg )looks a lot like what i believe became either the Pakled ship or the Bajoran Antares.. i think, anyway, my brain is full of ships. that nonsymmetrical outpinning on the side looks wicked familiar tho
|