This is topic The woman who killed her 5 children. Is her husband partially responsable? in forum The Flameboard at Flare Sci-Fi Forums.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
https://flare.solareclipse.net/ultimatebb.php/topic/11/716.html

Posted by MIB (Member # 426) on :
 
This little topic comes from my mother. I'm just relaying it here. The mighty flameboard!

The woman in question is pregnant with her 6th child! Yep. That's right. According to the news her mental problems started appearing while she was still pregnant with her 3rd child! So here's the question. Why the hell was her husband allowing here to become pregnant time after time when he knew she was having these menatl problems and was currently unable to cope??? Any comments?
 


Posted by Nimrod (Member # 205) on :
 
What, did she make five abortions? Or has she murdered five kids? Please add more info.
 
Posted by MIB (Member # 426) on :
 
She murdered her 5 kids. It's all over the news.
 
Posted by Jeff Kardde (Member # 411) on :
 
Andrea Yates. Houston, TX. Drowned her five children (ages 6 mos. to 7 years). She and her husband ("Rusty" -- anyone else think he drove a pickup with a gun rack and Hank Williams on the stereo?) were both religious (she, Roman Catholic; he, Methodist) and homeschooled their children (careful, Omega). Not that I'm saying that either of those played a role in her decision to kill them.

But, this is a rather big story here in the States. And I'm sure that some anti gun-control advocates will show this as proof positive that a tub full of water can be just as dangerous as guns. But I digress.
 


Posted by Nimrod (Member # 205) on :
 
I looked on CNN.com, this is so terrible. And those poor japanese kids was just last month.

I don't want to speculate about these things, sorry. I have so little information about the incident or the couple's life prior to this, prejudice would probably get in the way.
 


Posted by Siegfried (Member # 29) on :
 
I live in Houston, and the media circus with this is intense. First of all, the Harris County Sheriff's Department is refusing to release the results of the pregnancy test that is given to all female inmates as they are processed into the jail. It's a matter of confidentiality, they say. However, the department does have media leaks, and the story about Andrea Yates being pregnant yet again is false. At least, according to the local news the story is now confirmed as a rumor.

The story essentially goes as this so far: the Yates family lived in a suburb of Houston called Clear Lake. The father, Russell Yates, worked for NASA, and the mother, Andrea Yates, stayed home to care for and school their children. At the time this happened, they had five children ages 7 years to 6 months.

Andrea Yates has had a history of mental illness. She developed post-partum depression after the birth of her fourth child nearly two years ago. She was prescribed on three anti-depressants and one anti-psychotic drug prior to this tragedy. Her doctor, for reasons unknown, took her off of the anti-psychotic drug and replaced it with another anti-depressant.

On the day this happened, Andrea Yates took her five children and drowned them in the bath tub one at a time. As she was drowning the fourth child, the oldest son walked in on her. She chased him through the house, grabbed him, and drowned him, too. After this, Andrea Yates called her husband at NASA and told him to come home immediately. All she told him was that something had happened to the kids. She then called the Sheriff's department and asked for them to do a welfare check on her home.

The Sheriff deputy arrived at the house and found the children. The father arrived home as the medical examiner arrived. Andrea Yates is currently in the county jail on suicide watch. The funerals for the five children were held yesterday.

Yes, it is an extremely sad story.
 


Posted by TSN (Member # 31) on :
 
"Andrea Yates is currently in the county jail on suicide watch."

Personally, I'm surprised the husband/father hasn't killed himself. I can't even begin to imagine being able to deal w/ something like that...
 


Posted by Siegfried (Member # 29) on :
 
I really don't know how the father has been handling this. When the story first broke, one of the news stations showed footage of sherrif's deputies carrying Russell Yates out of his home; he was so distraught. The next day, he held a news conference outside his home where he expressed sorrow for the lost of his children, and then he said he still loved his wife completely in spite of all that has happened.

That statement outraged quite a few people who said he should not have been talking to the media that soon, how could he say he still loves his wife after she killed his kids, etc. That's been his only news conference. There has been footage of him attending the candlelight vigil held outside his home, being comforted by neighbors, at the children's wake, and at the funeral (which, I was incorrect about, it was today not yesterday). He's been getting raked over the coals on the morning radio shows here. People have been saying he's responsible for not picking up on the signals of his wife's inner demons.
 


Posted by Jeff Kardde (Member # 411) on :
 
That's kind of ridiculous.
 
Posted by Vogon Poet (Member # 393) on :
 
"Confirmed as rumour?" Isn't that an oxymoron?
 
Posted by First of Two (Member # 16) on :
 
quote:
has had a history of mental illness

quote:
birth of her fourth child

Is it just me, or doesn't anybody ELSE know that the situation should NEVER arise in which these two sentences are used together?

I'm sorry if this is a bit draconian, but people with mental illness shouldn't be having kids. It's irresponsible.

[ June 28, 2001: Message edited by: First of Two ]
 


Posted by Vogon Poet (Member # 393) on :
 
Yeah? What about people with Down's Syndrome?
 
Posted by First of Two (Member # 16) on :
 
Down's Syndrome isn't a mental illness.
 
Posted by Vogon Poet (Member # 393) on :
 
Fine, just so long as we agree on that. Because there are plenty of people out there who think it is.
 
Posted by Jeff Kardde (Member # 411) on :
 
My Uncle Duke has a very bad case of Down Syndrome -- I always get a haircut before visiting my grandparents (he lives with them on their farm in Princess Anne, MD) because he enjoys grabbing my hair and YANKING it.

On the other hand, my ex's sister also had Down Syndrome, but could carry on conversations, and interact with other people (as opposed to Duke, who gets up at 4, does a few chores around the farm, then sits in his underwear in front of the TV allnight).

...Fo2, rather surprised to hear you express that one sentiment.

I'm sorry if this is a bit draconian, but people with mental illness shouldn't be having kids. It's irresponsible.

I mean, people with mental illness generally can't regulate themselves to that bit. If they could reason: "gee, I'm sick in the head, I won't have any more kids", they wouldn't be mentally ill.

But the point I'm trying to make, is that it would essentially come down to the government (be that local, state, Federal or some combination of the three) to regulate the family habits of mentally ill patients.
 


Posted by First of Two (Member # 16) on :
 
You're right. Let me refine that statement:

People who KNOW that they're mentally ill shouldn't have children.

Generally, if you've been diagnosed, and are taking antidepressants/antipsychotics, you have a pretty good idea that you're mentally ill.

(And people who DON'T know that they're mentally ill should be TOLD.)
 


Posted by TSN (Member # 31) on :
 
"...how could he say he still loves his wife after she killed his kids..."

I don't understand how people could say that. If he loves her, he loves her. That shouldn't change just because she went insane. The whole kid-killing thing is irrelevant, really, because she didn't do it maliciously. I wouldn't expect him to hold it against her that she's a nutcase. "I loved you, and you went crazy on me! How dare you, you bitch!" Is that really what people expect? That's pretty sad, if they do...
 


Posted by MC Infinity (Member # 531) on :
 
-What the hell is Down Syndrome?

-I fail to see what difference this could have on a man's love for his wife. There are many people that still love people that are insane murderous psychopaths, you can't just turn love off(sure wish it was possible) because of a specific event or anything, but I beleive that it fades over time if you and your partner no longer see in eachother the reason why you love each other.

-From the brief synopsis, these people are pure rednecks, there is no denying it, anyone that has six children and homescools them is a redneck, and no one can convince me that I'm wrong.
 


Posted by Siegfried (Member # 29) on :
 
First of Two: I understand what you are trying to say, and I agree with it to a good extent, but it still needs refinement. I would say that people with a history of mental illness should not be allowed to raise children except in the case that the person(s) in question are in a treatment program that is having a positive effect. Once the condition of mental stability is assured, there should be no problems. Going strictly by your statement, I would be barred from fathering children for having clinical depression and suicidal tendencies (which, thankfully, have been lessening greatly the past two years).

TSN: I agree with your sentiment and a few others here. Love is not a light switch that can be flipped off when convenient. A lot of the people that have been expressing the opinion that the husband should be ashamed of loving his wife through this cannot seem to grasp that fact. Yes, his wife murdered their five children, but, with as much pain as he's going through, he should still love his wife. They've spent many years building a life together and raising a family. Yes, the wife has essentially gone insane with fury and wrecked all of their dreams. However, I perfectly understand his desire to support her and his ability to love her.
 


Posted by Nonsuch (Member # 356) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Jeff Kardde:
My Uncle Duke has a very bad case of Down Syndrome -- I always get a haircut before visiting my grandparents (he lives with them on their farm in Princess Anne, MD) because he enjoys grabbing my hair and YANKING it.

pardon the fact that this has absolutely nothing to do with the subject at hand, but I have to note that I live in Princess Anne, MD (or as I lovingly refer to it, East Bumfuck), and I find it surprising that anyone's ever HEARD of the town, much less has relatives here.

freaky.
 


Posted by PsyLiam (Member # 73) on :
 
My god, can the US not think up names for anything? The habit of stealing names from other countries, and occasionally adding "new" at the beginning was bad enough, but now you're taking the names of the British Royal Family for towns?

What's next? A town called "Tony Blair"? A street named "Vogon Poet"? A state called "PsyLiam"? Where will the madness end?
 


Posted by MC Infinity (Member # 531) on :
 
If they had a street named Psy Liam, I'd be making fun of them even more than I do now, wait I don't think that's possible seeing as thought I take every occassion to ridicule the US systems and policies
 
Posted by Sol System (Member # 30) on :
 
Oh yes, your cutting edge satire has got us quivering like bits of Jello stuck in a cyclotron.
 
Posted by Vogon Poet (Member # 393) on :
 
My amusement at that simile is damped by the sudden realisation I can't remember what a cyclotron is.
 
Posted by TSN (Member # 31) on :
 
A particle accelerator that's round.
 
Posted by MC Infinity (Member # 531) on :
 
Hmm... Very similar to how people here seem to feel about your penis
 
Posted by PsyLiam (Member # 73) on :
 
My dear God, I've GOT to use that as my new .sig
 
Posted by Jeff Kardde (Member # 411) on :
 
Nonsuch,

Small world! Dukhat's a Marylander, too. Yes, my family owns a few farms in Princess Anne -- my grandparents own one, and some grand-uncles and cousins own some others. My grandfather's farm is off Arden Station Rd. near Washington High (and close to "Dead Man's Curve")
 


Posted by The_Tom (Member # 38) on :
 
*explodes with laughter on reading Liam's .sig*
 
Posted by MC Infinity (Member # 531) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Sol System:
Oh yes, your cutting edge satire has got us quivering like bits of Jello stuck in a cyclotron.

I was ofcourse referring to the original remark about my satire, but I was foolish to think that anyone here has the mental capacity to get it.
 


Posted by Sol System (Member # 30) on :
 
Ooh, burn.
 
Posted by TSN (Member # 31) on :
 
Actually, I thought Infinity was talking about my comment, but that he was referring to Simon's genitals, and not mine.

So, regardless, Liam's sig is wrong. Especially since he attributes those words to Infinity, when I was the one who said them. :-)
 


Posted by MC Infinity (Member # 531) on :
 
It was supposed to fit in with all of the other "sol's penis" jokes, what I was implying that it is so big it makes people tremble like jello in a cyclotron. But forget it, y'all killed the joke........
 
Posted by Nimrod (Member # 205) on :
 
Well, to quote the immortal Adrian Cronauer...
 
Posted by PsyLiam (Member # 73) on :
 
Personally, I think I've turned it into a much better joke.

And it doesn't say that Infinity said that. Merely that he believes that. Do you see? Ahhhh.
 




© 1999-2024 Charles Capps

Powered by UBB.classic™ 6.7.3