Just curious for thoughts. I'm partial to Melissa Joan Hart for the role. What do you think?
Posted by Johnny (Member # 878) on :
Carol Marcus Explains It All (About Genesis)?
I hope they don't remake TWoK for so many reasons. I'd much prefer they came up with something original, preferably without using any existing races, space probes or characters for the enemy.
If they did remake TWoK there'd no doubt be huge arguments among fans about continuity, since the Botany Bay would most likely be of a different design and Khan's backstory would be changed to fit the new plot. The divergent timeline probably wouldn't explain much of it.
Posted by WizArtist II (Member # 1425) on :
There is also the fact that the New Timeline (N.T.) version of the Enterprise may never actually encounters the Botany Bay. Khan & crew could go on drifting through space for centuries or be found by another Starfleet vessel. Personally, I would think it beyond cheesy to try to 'remake' the old episodes/movies to fit N.T.
Posted by Sean (Member # 2010) on :
My thought on the matter is that, if they want to bring Carol Marcus into the franchise, and explain the back story (or at least, their version of it)between her and Kirk, by all means. I just hope they don't involve Kahn. We've been there. We don't need another TWOK.
I think though, that since this new franchise so to speak, seems to be about going back to Trek's origins, and the roots of it all (yes, I know they've changed things, but the basics are all there, that the Klingons are going to be somehow involved, in at least a semi-large way.
They're the one of the "fundamental bad guys" in Star trek. They've been there since the beginning, and it would be nice for them to come back. Even people who aren't huge trek fans know who the Klingons are, or have some basic idea ("they're the guys with the bumpy heads, right?") who they are. If in the next movie, they choose to introduce a new enemy race, or whatnot, fine by me, but I think any movie would benefit from having the Klingons involved in the plot somehow...and of course, I wouldn't complain if Carol Marcus was thrown in the mix. Technically, the history between her and Kirk (or, because of the time they did it ) directly influenced several of the movies and Kirk's character. If not for He and Carol having David, and David being killed by the Klingons, Kirk's attitude toward them might have been totally different, changing minor events throughout the following movies, and completely changing STVI.
![[Wink]](wink.gif)
) directly influenced several of the movies and Kirk's character. If not for He and Carol having David, and David being killed by the Klingons, Kirk's attitude toward them might have been totally different, changing minor events throughout the following movies, and completely changing STVI.![[Smile]](smile.gif)