T O P I C ��� R E V I E W
|
Jay the Obscure
Member # 19
|
posted
With apologies to Harry Shearer for borrowing his phrase, here is something for your outside the bubble news pleasure
I guess it takes an Irish reporter to get in the face of Mr. Bush, ask him the tough questions, and not back down when he gives evasive answers.
It's interesting to see Mr. Bush get testy when the interviewer does not follow the lap-dog way of American reporters.
He keeps giving stock answers and when the reporter tries to follow-up, he stops her and tells her to let him finish.
It's a classic.
www.rte.ie/news/2004/0624/primetime/primetime56_1c.smil
On a related note, while watching some of former President Clinton's interview on Larry King, I turned to someone and mentioned that I wished that the current resident of the White House could extemporize as well as Mr. Clinton when answering Mr. King�s wide-ranging questions.
|
WizArtist
Member # 1095
|
posted
Wasn't his extemporizing what was found on Lewinsky's dress?
|
Ultra Klackrent Zlatan Magnus
Member # 239
|
posted
No, that was sperm.
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
Anyone got a transcript of the exchange with reporters: CNN kept airing the blurb of some reporter shrilly saying "No, the world is NOT a safer place" after Bush's stock answer about how it is.
I'd like to see the whole thing though.
|
TSN
Member # 31
|
posted
"It's interesting to see Mr. Bush get testy when the interviewer does not follow the lap-dog way of American reporters.
"He keeps giving stock answers and when the reporter tries to follow-up, he stops her and tells her to let him finish." Did you notice the last time it happened, when they were talking about Palestine? She interrupted him and he stopped, looked at her like she was an idiot, then picked up in mid-sentence where he'd left off.
I don't know how it could be any more obvious that everything out of his mouth is pre-formulated. It's so rote that he can't even stop and insert a new idea into his train of thought (or lack thereof).
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
Not that interrupting during a press conference is at all professional though.
I think she was just trying to make him pissed enough for her to get a sound byte: sorta worked.
Not as much fun as Chaney (reportedly) saying "Fuck You" on the senate floor. (caught but not re-aired by CSPAN).
Where's the FCC regulators when you need them. HOward Stern must be spinning in his grave.
|
TSN
Member # 31
|
posted
Actually, I heard he said "go fuck yourself". But "fuck" was apparently in there someplace, anyway.
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
And to think, I used to look up to him... Oh, wait: I always thought he wasa shifty bastard.
Not related, but this should outrage anyone: http://www.cbc.ca/stories/2004/06/24/world/schmidt040624
|
TSN
Member # 31
|
posted
Apparently, that guy went to my high school. Of course, he graduated when I was two, but still...
|
Jay the Obscure
Member # 19
|
posted
quote: "The policy of the White House is that you submit your questions in advance, so they had my questions for about three days." -Carol Coleman, RTE.
Via Atrios
So now their all upset that she didn't follow the script.
quote: Angry White House pulls RTE interview
THE White House has lodged a complaint with the Irish Embassy in Washington over RTE journalist Carole Coleman's interview with US President George Bush.
And it is believed the President's staff have now withdrawn from an exclusive interview which was to have been given to RTE this morning by First Lady Laura Bush.
It is understood that both RTE and the Department of Foreign Affairs were aware of the exclusive arrangement, scheduled for 11am today. However, when RTE put Ms Coleman's name forward as interviewer, they were told Mrs Bush would no longer be available.
The Irish Independent learned last night that the White House told Ms Coleman that she interrupted the president unnecessarily and was disrespectful.
She also received a call from the White House in which she was admonished for her tone.
And it emerged last night that presidential staff suggested to Ms Coleman as she went into the interview that she ask him a question on the outfit that Taoiseach Bertie Ahern wore to the G8 summit.
Irish Independent
|
Jay the Obscure
Member # 19
|
posted
If a reporter asks questions, all you have to do is get through the interview and then not let the reporter or the news agency come back.
The rest of the press will get the message loud and clear.
If only they would band together and not let the White House bully them, we might get someplace. What I mean by that is if a reporter asks tough, but fair questions, and then is shut out by the White House, the next reporter, from the same or from some other news agency, needs to ask the same kind of tough, but fair questions as well, because the White House can't shut out everyone.
The news agencies should also not back down if the reporter asks tough, but fair questions. If the White House shuts the reporter out, the news agencies should express confidence in that reporter and send he or she back the next time to show that they can not be intimidated.
Instead, what we get is the next reporter meekly coming to Mr. Bush as a suppliant, seeking what the White House gives out. In doing so, the let the White House control the process and act like they have all the power.
The press does this because reporters don't want to loose their position and they don't want to get in trouble with their news agency. But when they do this, they shirk their responsibility to ask tough, but fair questions of the administration to try and get the information the public needs, but which this administration try to hide.
|
Capped in Mike
Member # 709
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by TSN: Actually, I heard he said "go fuck yourself". But "fuck" was apparently in there someplace, anyway.
i heard he said "the fuck."
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
IT's actuallt kind of refreshing that he's not ducking the issue but rather has stated that "he Vermont senator is the kind of guy that will attack you one minute and act like your buddy the next".
While I dont think the Senate floor should be the place for nmae-calling, I'm glad to see a politician stand behind his remarks (for once I can agree with Chaney on something: he's IS fucko).
|
TSN
Member # 31
|
posted
"...the White House can't shut out everyone." Yeah? Try them.
|
Jay the Obscure
Member # 19
|
posted
Yeah, I know. Sad, isn't it.
|
WizArtist
Member # 1095
|
posted
So if a reporter asks you "Do you still beat your wife?" that's ok? It's amazing to me that those who so viciously attack prepared statements tend to be the ones first in line to defend the statement "It all depends on the definition of IS"
|
Jay the Obscure
Member # 19
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by WizArtist: So if a reporter asks you "Do you still beat your wife?" that's ok? It's amazing to me that those who so viciously attack prepared statements tend to be the ones first in line to defend the statement "It all depends on the definition of IS"
Um, what?
|
Nim the Fanciful
Member # 205
|
posted
I just checked the Irish interview with Mr. Bush, the last segment (10:40 ->) is the best.
quote:
Bush: - Like Iraq, the palestinian and the Israeli issue is going to require...good security measures- Carol Coleman: - And a bit more evenhandedness from America?? - Ab...meh...*noticeable grunt*...we're working on security measures, and America -I'm the first president to ever have called for a palestinian state *preen*, that's, to me, sounds like a reasonably balanced approach.
|
Jay the Obscure
Member # 19
|
posted
Here is the transcript of interview.
His arguments are just so pathetic.
----
Interviewer - Mr. President, the Irish people are upset about the death toll in Iraq.
Answer - Americans are a compassionate people.
----
Interviewer - Mr. President, you didn't find any WMD?
Answer - We found that Saddam Hussein had a capacity for him to make a weapon. Did I mention Saddam was a bad man?
----
Interviewer - Mr. President, the world is more dangerous today post-Iraq invasion tan before.
Answer - Don't you remember September 11, 2001? I needed to work that in there somewhere. And other post Iraq invasion bombings around the world have nothing to do with what I did in Iraq. Nothing at all.
----
Interviewer - Mr. President, are you satisfied with the level of support you're getting from Europe? We both know no one other than Tony Blair supported you.
Totally Delusional Answer - Most of Europe supported the decision to invade Iraq. Except the French. You�re talking about the French aren�t you?
----
Interviewer - Mr. President, doesn't a solution to the to the Middle East mean doing something to solve the Israeli-Palestinian crisis and shouldn't you be doing something about it?
Totally Delusional Answer - There's a democracy in Turkey. And an emerging in Afghanistan. And a democracy in Pakistan. Democracy can emerge in the Palestinian state.
|
Nim the Fanciful
Member # 205
|
posted
They should put that as his term motto; "Let me finish!"
|
Veers
Member # 661
|
posted
quote: Interviewer - Mr. President, the world is more dangerous today post-Iraq invasion tan before.
Answer - Don't you remember September 11, 2001? I needed to work that in there somewhere. And other post Iraq invasion bombings around the world have nothing to do with what I did in Iraq. Nothing at all.
The train bombings in Madrid had nothing to do with invasion of Iraq?!! Is he serious?!!
quote: Interviewer - Mr. President, doesn't a solution to the to the Middle East mean doing something to solve the Israeli-Palestinian crisis and shouldn't you be doing something about it?
Totally Delusional Answer - There's a democracy in Turkey. And an emerging in Afghanistan. And a democracy in Pakistan. Democracy can emerge in the Palestinian state.
She wasn't talking about democracy, specifically. Plus--Pakistan has a democracy? He should have said a semi-democracy, if he wanted to be truthful. But we can't insult our allies, now can we?
|
Daryus Aden
Member # 12
|
posted
That interview was hilarious.
I wonder how many times he rehearsed the answers? I think that is what was irritating him so much....a question during speech could have made him look even sillier.
|
Nim the Merciful
Member # 205
|
posted
The best is when she says "more evenhandedness" in midsentence and he is noticeably irritated but can't stop the sentence he's already started.
|
Daryus Aden
Member # 12
|
posted
I think the problem was he didn't know which hand he should be using
|