T O P I C ��� R E V I E W
|
Dr. Phlox
Member # 878
|
posted
Hello, while I was lurking and waiting for my registration to come through, I had a delve through the old threads, but couldn't find anything on this subject, so I hope this hasn't been beaten to death already.
During DS9's "What You Leave Behind", one of the new shots from the battle shows the Defiant doing a barrel roll and you see this;

It looks to me like the Galaxy Class ship doesn't have a normal neck, I noticed it the first time I saw the episode, but never saw it mentioned on any of the main techy Trek sites. Is this new? Am I just looking at big shadow, hoping to have discovered something new?
It can't be the underside of a darknecked GCS since it barely has a neck at all. Doesn't look very structurally sound either.
Here are some more shots that might show it more clearly.
|
EdipisReks
Member # 510
|
posted
looks normal to me. you are seeing shadows case by the secondary hull. and what do you mean by the darknecks "barely having a neck"? they have the same neck as any other Galaxy class ship.
|
Dr. Phlox
Member # 878
|
posted
I meant this one doesn't seem to, I'm sure that's not a shadow. Maybe you have to see the actual clip to notice, or I could be wrong.
|
EdipisReks
Member # 510
|
posted
it's a shadow. i checked my video (it's a divx, actually, but close enough), and to me, it looks exactly like a shadow. you can see the sides of the neck going into the darkness. are you suggesting that the neck just gradually vaporizes to nothing on the sides?
|
Dr. Phlox
Member # 878
|
posted
No. I'm suggesting the back of the neck is slight a different shape though. I tried making the image brighter to show it more clearly. These clips are from a mpeg, so they're not very good quality(I do have the VHS though, I'm using this for caps though). 
I'm starting to think it might be a shadow too, but the top of the stardrive section doesn't look right to me. I don't think there would that dark a shadow.
|
EdipisReks
Member # 510
|
posted
the ship is the same one they were using for the rest of DS9. there is no difference.
|
Dat
Member # 302
|
posted
Looks like the same Galaxy to me. I really don't think a new model would have been created for the final episode with a good possibility it would never be used again. And I think Foundation was doing the CGI for this episode and at the time wasn't sure if a Galaxy would ever be used on Voyager again. So they wouldn't have bothered with a new model.
|
Dr. Phlox
Member # 878
|
posted
Oh well, it was nice theory. Actually it wasn't nice, but it was still a theory.
|
Sol System
Member # 30
|
posted
I don't remember this scene at all, though. Neat!
|
Vice-Admiral Michael T. Colorge
Member # 144
|
posted
This was part of a very fast scene where Sisko makes Nog do the manuver in the heat of the battle. By this time the Defiant was nearly out of quantum torpedoes.
|
AndrewR
Member # 44
|
posted
It's the shadow cast by the 'rounder' bits of the secondary hull. The light source is from BELOW/FRONT of the Galaxy, thus during these pics, the bottom of the Defiant would be in light (and the top dark (see pic) - as it is doing it's barrel roll. Just one thing though, if the Deffie does a barrel roll to avoid phaser, disruptor or torpedo fire - and they are all battling away in close quarters like they are seemingly in every battle, what happens to the torps etc that miss the barrel-rolling defiant, as in this picture they'd probably strike that Galaxy!!
|
EdipisReks
Member # 510
|
posted
i'm sure that GCS put more energy to shields when they saw Benjamin "Friendly Fire" Sisko coming towards them.
|