T O P I C ��� R E V I E W
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
So I was browsing around Google a few days ago and came upon this:
clicky
clicky
They're supposed to be wreckage from BoBW. They seem to be nacelles from the 1/1400 Enterprise-D kit.
EDIT: Too-wide images make the Baby Jesus cry [ June 17, 2013, 02:19 AM: Message edited by: Fabrux ]
|
Starship Freak
Member # 293
|
posted
What kind of context are we talking about? An auction? A fan? One of the original modelers?
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
These pics were taken along with pics of the Talarian warship and observation craft, so I suppose they were just taken by some TNG personnel...maybe whoever was in charge of storing the models?
|
Starship Freak
Member # 293
|
posted
Any new angles of the talarian ships?
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
Yep.
clicky
clicky
EDIT: Too-wide images make the Baby Jesus cry [ June 17, 2013, 02:18 AM: Message edited by: Fabrux ]
|
Starship Freak
Member # 293
|
posted
Nice, thank you!
|
o2
Member # 907
|
posted
Can you tell if this warp nacelles are Galaxy class, Nebula class or something else (hey, it could be even the remainging of two (sic!) Freedom class ships!)?
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
NIce shots of the Talarain ships! Too bad we could not see all that subtle paneling in the actual episode- back then all the ships had this crappy too-bright lighting which made them appear to be glowing- and a lot of detail was washed out as result.
Just look at the Ambassador- it's a featureless grey hull when seen on TV but the model has this complex blue pattern all over it.
Hmmm...despite years of rumors, it seems these models are NOT made from the old MPC Star destroyer model kits- I'm familliar with that particular inaccurate clusterfuck of a kit and trying to make the Talarian ships from that would be far more effort than just scratchbuilding them.
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by o2: Can you tell if this warp nacelles are Galaxy class, Nebula class or something else (hey, it could be even the remainging of two (sic!) Freedom class ships!)?
They seem to just be random wreckage, not from any specific ship. If one wanted to be anal-retentive, one could speculate that since they came from the Enterprise-D 1/1400 kit, that they were the remains of a Galaxy class ship.
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
The nacelles could be chunks of the USS Yamato. They can not however be part of the Freedom, as a piece of nacelle pylon clearly indicated it's not part of the horrid "frying pan" class.
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
The website I found these pics from stated specifically that it was Wolf 359 wreckage. And I don't believe we saw nacelles flying away when the Yamato exploded, only the saucer.
Oh, and I totally agree with you about the Talarian ships. They look much better and more believable like this, rather than that silly mustard yellow color they were given in post.
|
o2
Member # 907
|
posted
I compared the scene from BoBW, Part II with the above given pictures of the warp nacelles. The one in the episode (right under the Constitution class saucer section) is cut off somewhat after the Bussard collector. Therefore I would say that at least in this scene a different model warp nacelle has been used.
And since the picutre quality is better now in HD (not much better, but better) I would even say that there is no other scene where this warp nacelles could have been used.
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
Double post
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
Double post
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by o2: I compared the scene from BoBW, Part II with the above given pictures of the warp nacelles. The one in the episode (right under the Constitution class saucer section) is cut off somewhat after the Bussard collector. Therefore I would say that at least in this scene a different model warp nacelle has been used.
IIRC, that particular nacelle was custom-built by Greg Jein from the actual Enterprise-D mold, not built from model kits like these two were.
quote: And since the picutre quality is better now in HD (not much better, but better) I would even say that there is no other scene where this warp nacelles could have been used.
There's actually one object that might be a nacelle. It's long and thin, and can be seen during the scene right before the commercial break.
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
I can't win today, can I?
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
Hmmm...what did they use to destroy the Enterprise in the time-loop episode? What was the USS Odyssey made from when it blew up? Discounting a BOBW or USS Yamato origin, the nacelles could have been from either of those explosions...
|
Mars Needs Women
Member # 1505
|
posted
Could it be from the Niagara class, the ship that was positioned vertically when the E-D flew by? It always looked like the ship's nacelle were not connected to the body in that scene.
|
o2
Member # 907
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by Dukhat: There's actually one object that might be a nacelle. It's long and thin, and can be seen during the scene right before the commercial break.
Right, that could be a warp nacelle. But it also could be something else. Honestly I don't know...
|
o2
Member # 907
|
posted
quote: Originally posted by Mars Needs Women: Could it be from the Niagara class, the ship that was positioned vertically when the E-D flew by? It always looked like the ship's nacelle were not connected to the body in that scene.
The middle warp nacelle of the USS Princeton is damaged, and the picture of those two nacelles did not reflect this. Besides this, there is a back stage picture of the USS Princeton model, that clearly shows that the warp nacelles are a) connected to the ship and b) not galaxy-style.
|
Jason Abbadon
Member # 882
|
posted
Wait, waht? The USS Princeton had galaxy class nacelles- they were cast from the 4 footer's nacelles, IIRC.
|
Dukhat
Member # 341
|
posted
Correct. The pylons are not Galaxy-style, but the nacelles most certainly are.
|
o2
Member # 907
|
posted
I stand corrected.
|