Topic: An item to add to the list of inconsistencies
Trinculo
Ex-Member
posted
In the original ST:TNG Technical Manual, there is a class 10 cargo shuttlecraft. And,in the ST: DS9 Technical Manual, there is a class 10 personnel shuttlecraft. Can Starfleet have two class 10 shuttlecrafts?
[This message was edited by Trinculo on May 20, 1999.]
posted
For shuttles of different purposes, they certainly can. But if they made a Class-10 Personnel War Shuttle or something, that would be a different story :P
posted
There are Classes of shuttles and Types of shuttles. The shuttle in the DS9 Technical Manual is a Type 10 (possibly a Class 2, like Voyager's [transwarp] shuttle is a Class 2, Type 9).
------------------ "Isn't Y2K year 2048?? I mean last time I checked 1K was 1024. Now that Y1.953125K, that's where the real problem lies..."
[This message was edited by Altair on May 20, 1999.]
posted
The episode "Suspicions" has the Justman referred to as a Class 6 Shuttlecraft. The ST:TNG Technical Manual has the ship design listed as a Type 6 Shuttlecraft. From this evidence, type and class are interchangeable.
IP: Logged
posted
Maybe Voyager's crew decided that, since they're so far from Command, they can call the shuttles whatever they damn well please, and there's nothing anyone can do about it... :-)
------------------ "Sew, very old one! Sew like the wind!" -Martin Short, The Three Amigos
posted
They've come up with a pretty nice system over on the "official" tech. newsgroup, wherein a shuttle's class denotes its amount of internal space.
------------------ "You can't catch me where I'm gonna fall. You can't catch me where I'll hide. This world's too cold, this Nova rolls. I'm moving to the sun." -- They Might Be Giants
posted
How did the Borg know the class of the shuttlepod in "Dark Frontiers" if the crew of Voyager randomly decided the class? Further, along this point, why would cadets in the academy be able to coin a phrase to describe the working conditions aboard said shuttlepod? I see two possiblities for the class two and nine. 1. The class two and nine describe a shuttlecraft that shares a basic similarity in spaceframe design, yet has completely different technical specifications. (Class 15a and b and Class 16 shuttlepods of the ST:TNG technical manual.) 2. There was a change in the class designation. Up to the encyclopedia 2, the shuttlepod had no official class designation. The writers of the encyclopedia gave the shuttlepod a class designation. The writers of the series, either out of ignorance or deliberate intentions, changed the class designation. The class denotes internal space. Interesting, but contradicted by the known classes. The smallness of the shuttles gives an idea of the internal space. Class Two-Small Class Six-Medium Class Seven-Medium Class Eight-Medium Class Nine-Small Class 10 CS-Large Class 10 PS-Small to medium Class 15a, 15b, 16, 18-Small
The class numbers seem to be random. It would make more sense if the Class 10 CS was either at the low end of the scale (1 to 5) or the high end of the scale (15 to 20). The very small Class 18 would be at the opposite extreme to the Class 10 CS. The remaining shuttles would fit in between these two. If the scale were so ordered, then yes I would accept the idea that class denotes internal space.
A shuttle's type is its design. Type 6 is the standard TNG shuttle, for instance.
A shuttle's class is its size. So far, we've only seen a class 2 shuttle.
That's what I'm talking about. The discrepancy between the books is just a misuse of words. Current canon beats previous semicanon, after all.
------------------ "You can't catch me where I'm gonna fall. You can't catch me where I'll hide. This world's too cold, this Nova rolls. I'm moving to the sun." -- They Might Be Giants
posted
Trinculo: "How did the Borg know the class of the shuttlepod in "Dark Frontiers" if the crew of Voyager randomly decided the class? Further, along this point, why would cadets in the academy be able to coin a phrase to describe the working conditions aboard said shuttlepod?" If that was in reference to my comment, I was joking. I haven't seen Voyager in over a year, and I stopped following it, so I don't know what you're referring to. I was just trying to be funny, apparently w/ little, if any, success...
------------------ "There's always a bigger fish..." -Qui-Gon Jinn, Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
posted
The Type 9A comes from the TNG tech. manual...it's a cargo shuttle. Is that what you're asking?
------------------ "You can't catch me where I'm gonna fall. You can't catch me where I'll hide. This world's too cold, this Nova rolls. I'm moving to the sun." -- They Might Be Giants
Printer-friendly view of this topic
